Team Space for Collaborative Discussions/Problem Solving
Hi everyone,
Please use this space to mention any confusions (e.g. whether an answer is fit for approval) in this thread.
All team members are encouraged to subscribe to this space and reply to any doubts posted if they can!
If a question has been approved that shouldn't have been, what do we do with the pending answers?
Hypothetical question: I don't like myself.
There is no question, and it's hard to know if a question would be I don't like myself, is this normal?
I don't like myself, how do I change that?
The answers have to assume what the question is.
@AffyAvo
I've been wondering that too. I noticed one of the questions about self-harm was a bit graphic, and I'm not sure what to do about the answers
@AffyAvo @SnailPurple - what are your ideas on a solution?
Can you check if the Question Page itself has "published answers"? If not/even then we can try to 1) Edit the question 2) Consider removal/rejection
@SoulfullyAButterfly Ideally, the questions would be editted, or in some cases that Q&A question removed altogether.
@AffyAvo I agree please inform me if you ever spot a question that matches this presentation.
@SoulfullyAButterfly Ok, will watch for them and note them!
240260
I'm not sure about this one. Sounds like it could be a good answer but also could be phrased better? Phrased less as a personal reason and more of a "There could be many reasons, but these reasons are from my own experience. Maybe yours is similar" way? Am I being too picky?
@rebecca947 Sorry, missed this when it was there. Based on what you wrote though, I would approve, as long as it goes back to the question asked. Previously, personal experiences were valued as part of the answer, so I assume that's still the case.
@AffyAvo
Thank you ❤️
Seeing some of the editting suggestions, I think there are differences in how we do things.
These answers are being attributed to others - if something needs a great deal of editting, sentence structures reworked, etc. I reject it.
I approve things with reasonable amounts of slang, mintor gramatical errors. If it's commonly used, even if it isn't proper English, it goes through.
Leave for editting - spelling errors, more glaring grammatical errors that are simple fixes, has something that needs to be removed.
Is the goal to have a variety of fairly good even if not perfectly written answers, or are we trying to get the answer content more polished?
@AffyAvo I wouldn't say that we need extremely polished answers because the community guidelines for submission in itself are very standard/brief and everyone does have a style. would you like to tag the team so everyone is on the same page?
@SoulfullyAButterfly
Recently, I have come across answers with minor grammatical errors such as typing or spelling mistakes with 1 or 2 words. I did approve them as they were accurately written as per the guidelines. I reject/leave answers that have a lot of grammatical errors, are irrelevant, chaotic, and aren't answering the question.
@AffyAvo
Yeah, my style of editing is very thorough and I'm not sure if that's a good thing for this team. I leave for editing even if the answer has one minor error or needs a minor addition of punctuation. From your response, @SoulfullyAButterfly, I'm not too sure where you stand? What do you think would be a good middle ground? What would you reject and what would you accept?
As for slang, Affy, I tend to leave for editing. Slang and internet language constantly change and it depends on your generation what slang you understand. It also depends if you use certain sites. I only just discovered what 'poggers' means and '/' in front of letters (or something like that- clearly have forgotten the actual slang usage). I'm not sure if these are too niche of slang though. I know some people still don't know what ROFL and LOL mean...
@SoulfullyAButterfly
#240354
Im unsure where I stand on this answer. Not convinced by the last two sentences of the answer.
@GoldenRuleJG I would reject it. A fair bit of the answer isn't on topic and has a lot of stereotypes.
@AffyAvo Thanks for your input!
240961- "Running away may seem like a good idea at first, but you will come to realize it was a mistake.. the grass is greener on the other side." Is it just me or should that read "the grass is not always greener on the other side"?
#241503 The answer of what's there isn't bad, but it lacks a fairly critical part - seeking out help from someone who is properly trained. So reject due to the missing info or approve and allow for other answers to bring that up?
#248100
The response is overall good, but they mentioned a book title that has profanity in it. Is this acceptable to approve?
@SnailPurple Maybe astrix out the last 3 letters in the book?
Not a question:
My boyfriend told me he hooked up with someone else when we were on a break.
Answer #249493